ASD/LRFD Conversion

Quick Navigation: Design Methods

ASD to LRFD Conversion Overview

Converting between Allowable Stress Design (ASD) and Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) is frequently necessary when working with mixed design methods, evaluating existing structures, or converting component ratings for use in structural analysis.

The key concept: Both methods calculate the same wind pressures using identical ASCE 7 equations. The difference is in how those pressures are applied in load combinations and member design.

Load Factor Conversion Table

Conversion Direction	Formula	Example
ASD → LRFD	WLRFD ≈ 1.6 × WASD	WASD = 25 psf → WLRFD ≈ 40 psf
LRFD → ASD	WASD ≈ WLRFD / 1.6	WLRFD = 40 psf → WASD = 25 psf
Component DP Rating → LRFD	Required DP ≈ WLRFD / 1.6	WLRFD = 64 psf → Need DP-40 rating

Step-by-Step Conversion Examples

Example 1: Converting Component DP Rating for LRFD Use

Problem: You have a window rated DP-50 (ASD rating). Can it be used in an LRFD design where the calculated wind pressure is 75 psf?

Given:
Component DP rating = 50 psf (ASD nominal)
LRFD calculated pressure = 75 psf (strength level)

Step 1: Convert LRFD pressure to ASD equivalent
ASD equivalent = 75 psf / 1.6 = 46.9 psf

Step 2: Compare to component rating
Component DP-50 > 46.9 psf required

Answer: ✓ YES - DP-50 window is adequate
(50 psf > 46.9 psf, with 6% margin)

Example 2: ASD Beam Design with LRFD Wind Loads

Problem: Structural analysis provided LRFD factored loads. You want to check beam using ASD method.

Given:
LRFD factored wind load = 1,200 lb/ft (from 1.2D + 1.0W)
Dead load D = 400 lb/ft

Step 1: Back-calculate unfactored wind load
1,200 = 1.2(400) + 1.0(W)
1,200 = 480 + W
W = 720 lb/ft

Step 2: Apply ASD load combination
w_ASD = D + 0.6W
w_ASD = 400 + 0.6(720)
w_ASD = 832 lb/ft

Use 832 lb/ft for ASD beam design

Example 3: Converting Existing ASD Design to LRFD

Problem: Evaluate existing building designed using ASD with new LRFD analysis.

Given:
Existing design: ASD with p = 30 psf wind pressure
Original: D + 0.6W combination

Step 1: The wind pressure remains the same
p = 30 psf (this doesn't change)

Step 2: Apply LRFD load combinations
Check: 1.2D + 1.0W (with p = 30 psf)
Check: 0.9D + 1.0W (uplift, with p = 30 psf)

Step 3: Verify with LRFD resistance
Use φR_n instead of allowable stresses

Note: Members designed for ASD may have different
capacity ratios under LRFD due to φ factors

Detailed ASD ↔ LRFD Comparison

Design Aspect	ASD Approach	LRFD Approach	Conversion
Wind Pressure Calc	p = qh[(GCp)-(GCpi)]	p = qh[(GCp)-(GCpi)]	SAME - no conversion needed
Load Combination	D + 0.6W	1.2D + 1.0W	Load factor ratio ≈ 1.6
Uplift Combination	0.6D + 0.6W	0.9D + 1.0W	Depends on D/W ratio
Steel Flexure	fb ≤ Fb = 0.6Fy	Mu ≤ φMn (φ=0.90)	Different equations
Component Rating	DP-40 = 40 psf nominal	Convert: 40 × 1.6 ≈ 64 psf	Multiply by 1.6
Terminology	"Nominal" wind loads	"Ultimate" wind loads	Same pressure, different name

When Conversion is Necessary

Common Conversion Mistakes to Avoid

WRONG: Multiplying wind pressure (psf) by 1.6 to convert ASD to LRFD
RIGHT: Wind pressure stays THE SAME. Only load factors and resistance factors change.

WRONG: Using DP-40 component with 64 psf LRFD pressure directly
RIGHT: Convert LRFD pressure to ASD equivalent (64/1.6 = 40 psf), then compare to DP rating

WRONG: Assuming 1.6 factor applies to all situations equally
RIGHT: Recognize 1.6 is approximate - exact conversion depends on dead-to-wind load ratio